Why an eSIM can fail where the vendor says it works
A vendor's coverage list usually means "we have a roaming agreement with at least one network in this country". It doesn't promise that the agreement covers every network, every region, 4G or 5G, or your phone model. Here are the common reasons, roughly from most to least frequent.
1. The roaming route doesn't reach the local network you're on
Travel eSIMs roam through their home operator's agreements, sometimes via a roaming hub. If that route has a deal with only one local network, you only get service where that network has coverage. If the deal has lapsed or excludes data, you get "no service" or "emergency calls only" even with full signal bars.
2. Coverage differs by region, not just by country
The partner network may cover the capital but not the provinces. One traveller's Airalo plan in Papua New Guinea worked in Port Moresby but not in Mount Hagen or Goroka in the Highlands. This is why eSIM Doctor stores results by region and town.
3. The network refuses your phone model
Networks can check the phone's IMEI and model code (TAC) and refuse handsets they don't consider compliant. The phone receives a reject code such as cause 6, "illegal ME". In Australia we recorded exactly this: a Xiaomi 14T refused with cause 6 through Airalo and Maya, while a Vodafone travel eSIM worked on the same phone. The check is applied per roaming route, so one vendor can work where another doesn't.
4. No 3G fallback, and calls need VoLTE
Many countries have switched off 3G (Australia and the US among them). A phone or eSIM profile without working 4G calling (VoLTE), or a roaming deal that only covered 3G, can end up with no service or data only. Some regulators also require that every phone can reach emergency services over 4G, which networks enforce through the handset checks above.
5. Settings on the phone
- Data roaming is off for the travel eSIM.
- The travel eSIM isn't the mobile data SIM.
- The APN is missing or wrong (signal, but no internet).
- Network selection is stuck on one network that doesn't accept the eSIM.
- The phone is carrier-locked.
6. The plan itself
Not activated yet, expired, used up, or sold for a different country or region package. In these cases the phone connects but the internet check fails.
How to tell which one it is
Most of these look the same on the phone: "no service" or no internet. The difference is in what the network answers, which Android doesn't show you. The eSIM Doctor app's Diagnose mode records those answers (reject codes, refused data connections) and names the cause.